What happened. Apartment owners in many Riga apartment buildings have received a notice from AS “Rīgas namu pārvaldnieks” (RNP) about a recalculation of the water consumption difference. RNP will recalculate the difference charged 5–10 years ago, split it among all apartment owners in the building and add it to their regular management bills. As grounds, RNP cites Constitutional Court judgments in cases No. 2023-46-03, No. 2024-17-03 and No. 2025-35-03.
What the Constitutional Court decided. These judgments found that Cabinet of Ministers rules under which only a few owners paid the building’s entire water consumption difference were incompatible with Article 105 of the Constitution. Those were owners who hadn’t submitted meter readings for three months, who had no meters installed, or whose meters hadn’t been verified on time. The court held that putting the whole burden on a few people, regardless of why the difference arose, is disproportionate.
However, the court declared these rules invalid only for the parties to specific court cases and for people whose cases are still pending. None of the judgments requires managers to recalculate the difference in every building for every year.
Our position. ASaimnieks believes RNP’s planned recalculation has no legal basis, for three reasons.
1. The manager’s risk is not the owners’ debt. The Residential Property Management Law requires a manager to manage the building professionally and to apply the law correctly. If a manager applied rules that were later found unconstitutional, and now has to refund money to individual owners, that is a risk of its own business. The apartment owners as a whole are not responsible for it.
2. The claim is most likely time-barred. The recalculation covers a period 5–10 years ago, but a manager’s claims expire after three years. The manager is a commercial company, and its claims against apartment owners for management and utility charges arise from a commercial transaction. In our view, this means the right to demand payment for most of the recalculated period has already been lost. That is exactly what limitation periods are for: so that no one can bill people years later for a period that can no longer be checked — the meter readings, the building’s water balance and the calculations of the time are long archived or no longer available.
3. The bill reaches the wrong people. Over these years many apartments have been sold, bought or inherited. Someone who bought their apartment in 2022 didn’t live there or use any water back then. On top of that, RNP no longer manages many of these buildings. It is unclear on what legal basis a former manager can issue new charges for such an old period.
Questions for the Ministry of Economics. The Ministry of Economics is the lead authority for housing policy and residential property management. We believe it should give a clear answer to three questions:
- Does a former manager that no longer manages a building have the right to recalculate and bill owners for past periods?
- Hasn’t the limitation period set by the Civil Law or the Commercial Law expired for a claim over a water consumption difference from 5–10 years ago?
- How are owners who bought their apartment after the recalculated period protected, and may a manager’s losses be passed on to the other owners at all?
What to do if you received a notice or a bill.
- Before you pay, ask RNP in writing for the calculation: which period, what amount and on what legal basis.
- Submit a written objection and state that, in your view, the claim is time-barred.
- Don’t sign any acknowledgment of the debt — it can interrupt the limitation period.
- If you bought or inherited your apartment after the recalculated period, say so in your objection.
- If ASaimnieks manages your building, contact us at +371 28800303 or info@asaimnieks.lv — we’ll help you prepare the objection.
This article reflects the views of SIA ASaimnieks and is not legal advice.
Save or send this article
An easy way to come back to it later, or share it with your neighbours.